Pizza restaurants

Cafora's Pizza Italian Restaurant

4.5 703 reviews Closed 2885 Main St, Newfane, NY 14108, United States

Discover this place

Cafora's Pizza Italian Restaurant, nestled in the heart of Newfane, NY, is a beloved gem offering a delightful mix of traditional and innovative Italian cuisine. Family-owned for over 50 years, Cafora's prides itself on its warm, welcoming atmosphere and exceptional service. Reviewers highlight the vast menu, from mouthwatering pizzas to generous pasta dishes, all at reasonable prices. Diners rave about the thin-crust pizza, cooked to perfection, and the standout spinach garlic bread appetizer that elevates the dining experience. The Buffalo Chicken Salad and hearty Chicken Parmesan are also crowd favorites, showcasing the restaurant’s commitment to quality ingredients. Customer service receives consistent praise, with staff going above and beyond to ensure a memorable visit. Unique offerings like the "Chubby Challenge" add a fun twist for adventurous eaters, further enhancing its charm. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Cafora's proves to be a must-visit culinary stop. With its delicious food, friendly ambiance, and dedicated service, it's no surprise that patrons are willing to travel long distances just to savor a meal here. Truly, Cafora's Pizza Italian Restaurant embodies the heart of Italian dining with every bite.

Photos

Cafora's Pizza Italian Restaurant - Photo 1

Cafora's Pizza Italian Restaurant - Photo 2

Cafora's Pizza Italian Restaurant - Photo 3

Cafora's Pizza Italian Restaurant - Photo 4

Cafora's Pizza Italian Restaurant - Photo 5

Amenities & More

Service options

Delivery
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights

Fast service
Great wine list
Serves local specialty

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Counter service
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual
Cozy
Quiet

Crowd

Family-friendly
Groups
Tourists

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Cafora's Pizza Italian Restaurant before visiting.

Reviews for Cafora's Pizza Italian Restaurant

4.5

703 reviews

100%

24%

Review highlights

Based on 703 reviews

Cafora's Pizza Italian Restaurant in Newfane, NY, is widely praised for its authentic Italian cuisine and extensive menu featuring both classic and inventive dishes. Customers frequently highlight the consistently delicious food, with particular appreciation for their thin-style pizzas and generous portions. The family-owned establishment is noted for its welcoming, clean atmosphere and attentive, friendly service, making it a popular choice for both small and large groups, including families with children. Reasonably priced offerings and unique challenges like the "Chubby Challenge" add to the restaurant's charm. Overall, Cafora's maintains a strong reputation for quality, warmth, and a satisfying dining experience that attracts repeat customers from near and far.

mike branch

May 12, 2025

We came in with a large party for Mother's Day. We came early, when the doors opened. We all ordered dinner entrees. We had small children with us. The food was excellent . The spinach garlic bread appetizer was superb. Our waitress was the best...couldn't ask for better. Thanks for the great food and service!

Brynna Malen

Mar 08, 2025

If you live or visit anywhere within driving distance to Newfane, I STRONGLY recommend you stop in for a meal at Cafora's! They have a vast and extensive menu full of classic and original Italian meals! Family owned and ran for 50 years. Charming and quaint environment with extremely reasonable prices! They even have a "CHUBBY CHALLENGE". If you can eat an entire Chubby in 30 minutes or less you can win a 10 gift certificate AND get on the Wall Of Shame!!! I definitely will be coming in regularly to try more menu items! Lourie was a friendly and fun server who recommended an amazing meal for me.

Rickylee Smith

Mar 02, 2025

Pretty consistent and a lot of great tasting items on there menu. There thin style pizza cooked well done is one of my favorite pizzas

D C

Feb 27, 2025

I’ve been a customer for many years and my husband is a die hard fan of their pizza so anytime we are in newfane we order a large to take home. Always polite, quick and delicious!

Dave Jurenko

Feb 25, 2025

My family and I travel an hour and a half just to come here to eat. They have great food. Big portions. The waitress are always friendly and the place is always clean. We have 5 people in our family and we never have to wait long to be seated. My wife had the chicken parmesan, our 2 girls had the spaghetti and meatballs, my son had the pizza and fries and I had a steak pazone. Everything was delicious and the prices are reasonable.

Karen Dunch

Feb 19, 2025

My husband and I always enjoy the food, wait staff and the atmosphere. I recommend the restaurant highly.

Gangesh Yadav

Feb 12, 2025

Have visited this place thrice and it has been awesome all the time. Delicious food with great serving size and warm welcome staff makes you feel like home. Accommodate people with special food requests. They have pizza theatre where you can watch cook making pizza. Order comes with warm bread and it is best tasting bread that i have ever tasted.

Betsy Wisto

Feb 11, 2025

Great food reasonably priced and very large portions. Service was great and extremely friendly. It's comfort food at it's best. I have yet to try the pizza and wings but I'm looking forward to it. Every person I've met who has been there before has nothing but good things to say. I'm in total agreement. Also the homemade bread is outstanding.